Our Methodology

How we analyze and rate over 7,200 dog food products

Rating Overview

Our health score is a comprehensive rating from 0-100 that reflects the overall nutritional quality and safety of a dog food product. The score is derived from analyzing over 50 individual factors across five key categories.

80-100

Excellent

Top-tier nutrition

60-79

Good

Meets basic standards

0-59

Needs Improvement

Consider alternatives

Scoring Categories

Protein Quality (25%)

We analyze the protein sources, their position in the ingredient list, and whether they come from whole meats, meals, or by-products. Named protein sources (e.g., 'chicken' vs 'poultry') score higher.

Named meat sourceWhole meat vs mealPosition in ingredient listProtein diversity

Ingredient Quality (25%)

We evaluate each ingredient for nutritional value, digestibility, and potential health concerns. Whole foods score higher than processed alternatives. Controversial fillers and artificial additives are penalized.

Whole food ingredientsAbsence of fillersNo artificial preservativesNo artificial colors/flavors

Nutritional Balance (20%)

We check guaranteed analysis values against optimal nutritional profiles for dogs. This includes protein-to-fat ratios, carbohydrate content, and the presence of essential vitamins and minerals.

Protein contentFat contentCarbohydrate levelVitamin/mineral profile

Safety Record (15%)

We track recall history, manufacturing practices, and any reported safety issues. Products from manufacturers with strong safety records receive higher scores.

Recall historyManufacturing standardsQuality controlSourcing transparency

Value Indicators (15%)

We assess whether the nutritional quality justifies the price point and compare similar products within the same category to ensure fair ratings.

Ingredient-to-price ratioCategory comparisonFeeding cost per dayNutritional density

Data Sources

Our analysis is based on multiple data sources to ensure accuracy and comprehensiveness:

  • Product labels and guaranteed analysis from manufacturer websites
  • Peer-reviewed nutritional research and veterinary publications
  • Industry safety records and manufacturing certifications
  • Professional veterinary nutritionist consultations
  • Consumer feedback and reported experiences

Our Independence

BetterPets does not accept payment from pet food manufacturers to influence our ratings. All products are evaluated using the same objective methodology regardless of brand, price point, or advertising relationships. Our commitment to independence ensures that pet parents can trust our recommendations are based solely on product quality.

Ready to check your dog's food?

See how your current food scores using our methodology

Start Free Food Check
← Back to Home